Iowa Civil Jury Verdicts

<< previous page next page >>

Trial Date	Venue	Case Type	Case Number	Case Name	Plaintiff's Attorney	Defendant's Attorney	Judge	Plaintif for Defendant	Verdict Amount	Verdict	Statement of Case
05/24/2021	Black Hawk County	CONTRACT/COMMERICAL - OTHER	LACV137917	MARILYN FAIRCHILD VS DJBCK	ERICH PRIEBE 3151 BROCKWAY RD PO BOX 810 WATERLOO, IA 50704 business: (319) 234-4471 LAURA LEE FOLKERTS 3151 BROCKWAY ROAD PO BOX 810 DUTTON DANIELS HINES KALKHOFF COOK SWANSON PLC WATERLOO, IA 50704 business: (319) 234-4471	HENRY J BEVEL III 528 W 4TH ST SWISHER AND COHRT PLC PO BOX 1200 WATERLOO, IA 50704 business: (319) 232-6555	ANDREA DRYER			Plaintiff $46,105.58
05/21/2021	Woodbury County	CONTRACT/COMMERICAL - OTHER	LACV178245	WIGGS, DOUG & BARBARA V. STATE FARM FIRE & CASUALTY CO ET AL	DAVID L REINSCHMIDT 600 4TH STREET SUITE 303 P.O. BOX 912 SIOUX CITY, IA 51102 business: (712) 233-3635	GUY RICHARD COOK 500 EAST COURT AVENUE SUITE 200 DES MOINES, IA 50309 business: (515) 245-4300 LAURA N MARTINO 500 E COURT AVE STE 200 PO BOX 10434 DES MOINES, IA 50306 business: (515) 245-4300 CLARK IAN MITCHELL 500 EAST COURT AVENUE SUITE 200 DES MOINES, IA 50309 business: (515) 245-4300 SEAN MICHAEL CORPSTEIN 500 E COURT AVE, SUITE 200 GREFE & SIDNEY P.L.C. DES MOINES, IA 50309 business: (515) 245-4300	JEFFREY A NEARY			The jury found in favor of the Defendant and against the Plaintiffs on the claim for breach of contract and awarded no damages to the Plaintiffs.	Doug Wiggs and Barbara Wiggs reside in Sioux City, Iowa. On November 24, 2013, and at Plaintiffs’ farm property, there was a fire loss. State Farm insured the Plaintiffs’ property at the time of the loss and issued indemnity payment thereafter totaling more than $569,000. Following State Farm’s indemnity payments, the Plaintiffs submitted an additional inventory. In response to this final inventory, State Farm requested additional documentation to substantiate the claimed items. Among these items were over $300,000 worth of Snap-On tools.
05/28/2021	Polk County	Other	EQCE084694	DSM CIVIL AND HUMAN RIGHTS COMM VS PATRICK KNUEVEN ET AL	LUKE MICHAEL DESMET 400 ROBERT D RAY DRIVE DES MOINES, IA 50309-1891 business: (515) 283-4110 MICHELLE RAE MACKELWIEDERANDERS 400 ROBERT D. RAY DRIVE DES MOINES, IA 50309 business: (515) 283-4537	JACQUELINE K SAMUELSON 699 WALNUT STREET STE 2000 DES MOINES, IA 50309 business: (515) 288-6041 JOHN F FATINO 699 WALNUT STREET SUITE 2000 DES MOINES, IA 50309 business: (515) 288-6041 NICHOLAS JAMES GRAL	SARAH E CRANE			On 5/20/2021, the Jury returned a verdict after jury trial. The jury found no liability as to Defendant Mary Knueven. The jury found no liability as to Patrick Knueven on Count I, but did find liability as to Patrick Knueven on Count II and awarded a civil penalty of $50,000. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that judgment in the amount of $50,000 is hereby entered in favor of Plaintiff Des Moines Civil and Human Rights Commission and against Defendant Patrick Knueven on Count II. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all claims against Mary Knueven are hereby dismissed and that Count I against Patrick Knueven is hereby dismissed.
05/28/2021	Polk County	EMPLOYMENT CLAIM - OTHER	LACL144995	ALLYN WAYNE ROBERTS VS CITY OF DES MOINES	MATTHEW RYAN DENNING 2423 INGERSOLL AVENUE DES MOINES, IA 50312 business: (515) 277-6559 AMY RACHELLE BECK 8831 WINDSOR PARKWAY FIEDLER LAW FIRM PLC JOHNSTON, IA 50131	LUKE MICHAEL DESMET 400 ROBERT D RAY DRIVE DES MOINES, IA 50309-1891 business: (515) 283-4110 JOHN O HARALDSON 400 ROBERT D RAY DRIVE CITY OF DES MOINES LEGAL DEPT DES MOINES, IA 50309-1891 business: (515) 283-4072	SCOTT J BEATTIE			The Plaintiff, by and through the undersigned, and hereby dismisses the above captioned matter with prejudice. The parties sign off for their respective costs
05/05/2021	Polk County	MOTOR VEHICLE	LACL145884	JOHN PAUL ROYER VS JARED PAUL MUMFORD	JONATHAN NOEL GARNER 303 LOCUST STREET, STE. 300 HOMESTEAD BUILDING DES MOINES, IA 50309	JACK WILLIAM LEVERENZ 2400 NW 86TH STREET, SUITE 25 DES MOINES, IA 50322 BRYANT JAMES HICKIE 2400 NW 86TH STREET, SUITE 25 DES MOINES, IA 50322 MATTHEW PAUL SCHWARTZKOPF 2400 NW 86TH ST., STE 25 DES MOINES, IA 50322	MICHAEL D HUPPERT			IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that judgment entered is in favor of the Plaintiff, John Paul Royer, and against the Defendant, Jared Paul Mumford, in the amount of $38.727.33 plus interest at the legal rate. Court costs are taxed to the Defendant.	This case arises out of a motor vehicle collision on October 10, 2017. On this date, Plaintiff John Paul Royer (“Plaintiff”), was at the intersection of S.E. National Drive and S.E. Delaware Avenue, in Ankeny, Iowa. Plaintiff had a green turn arrow and began to move his vehicle through the intersection. Defendant Jared Paul Mumford was traveling southbound on S.E. Delaware Avenue. He mistakenly entered the subject intersection while the traffic signal was red, which caused his vehicle to impact the driver’s side of Plaintiff’s vehicle. Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against Defendant, and alleges that Defendant was negligent and is liable for personal injury and damages stemming from the accident. Defendant admits that his negligence was the cause of the accident.
05/17/2021	Polk County	PI - MOTOR VEHICLE	LACL146209	ANTHONY GLOEDE VS SKYLAR THOMAS MEINECKE	NATHAN LEE VOS 4090 WESTTOWN PKWY SUITE 110 WEST DES MOINES, IA 50266 business: (515) 346-8776 JORDAN RYAN HUTCHINSON 4090 WESTOWN PARKWAY SUITE 102 HUTCHINSON LAW FIRM PLC WEST DES MOINES, IA 50266 business: (515) 216-0624	BRYANT JAMES HICKIE 2400 NW 86TH STREET, SUITE 25 DES MOINES, IA 50322 business: (515) 277-6550	SAMANTHA GRONEWALD			Trial was held on May 17-19, 2021 in this case. On May 19, 2021, the jury returned a unanimous verdict awarding the plaintiff a total of $8,200 in past damages. Accordingly, judgment on the jury’s verdict should be entered.
04/19/2021	Polk County	EMPLOYMENT CLAIM - OTHER	LACL146265	TRACY WHITE VS STATE OF IOWA AND IOWA DHS	MADISON ELIZABETH FIEDLER-CARLSON FIEDLER LAW FIRM PLC 8831 WINDSOR PARKWAY JOHNSTON, IA 50131 PAIGE E FIEDLER 8831 WINDSOR PARKWAY FIEDLER LAW FIRM PLC JOHNSTON, IA 50131 business: (515) 254-1999	MADISON ELIZABETH FIEDLER-CARLSON FIEDLER LAW FIRM PLC 8831 WINDSOR PARKWAY JOHNSTON, IA 50131 PAIGE E FIEDLER 8831 WINDSOR PARKWAY FIEDLER LAW FIRM PLC JOHNSTON, IA 50131 business: (515) 254-1999	HEATHER L LAUBER			NOW on May 20, 2021, the jury having returned a verdict for the Plaintiff in this matter, the Court enters the following judgment based upon the verdict: Judgment is entered for the Plaintiff and against the Defendants in the amount of SEVEN HUNDRED NINETY THOUSAND DOLLARS ($790,000.00) with interest at the lawful rate for past emotional distress ($260,000.00) from the date of the filing of the petition in this matter and interest at the lawful rate for future emotional distress ($530,000.00) from May 20, 2021, plus court costs. Attorneys’ fees shall be determined at a later date by supplemental order. The Court finds that the fees and expenses sought by the Plaintiff are reasonable and meet all the elements for an award of fees in cases similar. Therefore, Plaintiff’s Motion for Attorney Fees is GRANTED. IT IS THE ORDER OF THE COURT that the Plaintiff is hereby awarded attorney fees and expenses as well as court costs to be paid by the Defendant in the amounts as follows: $399,202.50 for attorney fees. $26,212.50 for legal assistant and law clerk fees. $11,530.90 for litigation expenses. Total: $436,945.90
04/15/2025	Winneshiek County	Civil - Other Action	EQCV026863	Christine Bentley Schlitt, et al v. Roger Bentley, et al	Spencer Steven Cady, Matthew McGuire, and Jay Patrick Syverson	Thomas C. Verhulst	John Bauercamper			MISTRIAL - Jury unable to reach verdict.	In this case, the Plaintiffs claim that Genevive I. Bentley created and executed a Will and Revocable Trust on August 11, 2017 and a Will and Revocable Trust on July 17, 2019. Plaintiffs further claim that the 2017 and 2019 Wills and Trusts of Genevieve I. Bentley are invalid and unenforceable because the Wills and Trusts were the result of undue influence exercised upon Mrs. Bentley by the Defendants at the time the Wills and Trusts were created and executed. The Defendants deny that they unduly influenced the Genevieve I. Bentley to create and execute the Wills and Trusts executed by Mrs. Bentley in 2017 and 2019.
08/15/2019	Kossuth County	PI - MOTOR VEHICLE	LACV027226	HEUN, KEVIN & HEUN,SUSAN VS HENDERSON,BONNIE MAREE ET AL	A JOHN FREY JR	RYLAND LEE DEINERT CLARK IAN MITCHELL	CHARLES K BORTH			Plaintiff's verdict: Past medical - $143.17	This lawsuit arises out of an automobile collision which occurred on July 17, 2016, in the city of Algona, Kossuth County, Iowa. In this case plaintiffs Kevin Heun and Susan Heun claim they sustained injuries and damages as a result of the motor vehicle collision. Susan was the driver of a pickup truck in which Kevin was a passenger. Plaintiffs claim Defendant Bonnie Maree Henderson was at fault for the collision and she is therefore responsible under the law to compensate Plaintiffs for their damages. The Defendant denies fault and contends Susan Huen was at fault for the collision.
03/28/2016	Carroll County	Plaintiff shot in leg when defendant 1 attempted to disarm another defendant 2. Defendant 1 denies he was at fault. Defendant 2 admits at least some fault. Defendants also claim plaintiff was at fault.	LACV039158	Davis v. Kasperbauer et al.	Aaron Ahrendsen	Gina Badding Jeffrey Minnich				Plaintiff's verdict. Defendant 1 - 10%, Defendant 2 - 80%, Plaintiff - 10%. Past meds - $6,946.41. Past P/S - $15,000.
09/18/2017	Johnson County	Dramshop	CVCV076660	Timothy Cole v. Moose Lodge #1096 and Todd White	Abigail Brown Steve Ballard	Benjamin J. Samuelson				Plaintiff's verdict - $70,000 for willful disregard for safety	This case arises from an attack by Todd Douglas White (“Todd White”) on Plaintiff, Timothy Cole (“Tim Cole”) at Defendant Iowa City Lodge Number 1096, Loyal Order of Moose dba Loyal Order of Moose Lodge (“Moose Lodge”). Tim Cole sustained injuries and damages as a result of the attack. In this case, Tim Cole claims that Moose Lodge is responsible for his injuries and damages because Moose Lodge, through its agents and employees, furnished liquor, beer, or both to Todd White to the point where Todd White became intoxicated or at a time when Todd White was already intoxicated. Intoxication was one cause of Todd White’s physical attack of Plaintiff. Tim Cole further claims that that Moose Lodge is responsible for his injuries and damages because Moose Lodge was negligent in inadequately training it employees; inadequately staffing its security personnel; failing to supervise employees; or otherwise failing to exercise reasonable care under all circumstances for the protection and safety of its patrons, including Tim Cole. Tim Cole further claims that that Moose Lodge is responsible for his injuries and damages because Moose Lodge failed to use reasonable care in its selection and hiring of its employees and staff; failed to use reasonable care in its training and supervising of employees and staff; failed to use ordinary care to keep patrons, including Todd White, from being intoxicated; failed to provide trained security personnel to protect patrons; or otherwise failed to use ordinary care to keep its premises safe and protect its patrons, including Tim Cole. E-FILED 2017 SEP 18 10:40 AM JOHNSON - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT Tim Cole also claims that Todd white is responsible for his injuries and damages that resulted from the battery.
02/09/2023	Johnson County	Breach of Contract; Breach of 91A / Iowa Wage Payment Collection Law; Expedited Civil Action	LACV083194	CARRIE KASPER V. LEGACY ELITE ESCROW, ET AL.	Abigail Brown	Kevin Visser	Valerie L. Clay	Plaintiff	9344.31	For plaintiff Damages: $9,344.31 TOTAL DAMAGES: $9,344.31, plus attorney fees requested	In this case Plaintiff Carrie Kasper claims that Defendant Legacy Elite Escrow, Inc. failed to make a 401(K) contribution under an employment agreement between herself and Defendant. The Defendant denies Plaintiff’s claims and states that Defendant had no obligation to make a 401(K) contribution on Plaintiff’s behalf.
12/09/2019	Linn County	PI - OTHER NEGLIGENCE	LACV089801	DUSTIN KINDIG VS SPENCER NEWMAN ETAL	ADAM C. WITOSKY MATTHEW M BOLES CHRISTOPHER CLARK STEWART	JACE TYRONE BISGARD KARLA J SHEA WILLIAM HENRY ROEMERMAN KELLY WAYNE OTTO	IAN K THORNHILL			Defense verdict	In this case, Plaintiff, Dustin Kindig, is seeking recovery from the Defendants, Spencer Newman and Josh Burns for bodily injuries he claims to have sustained as the result of an October 21, 2017 assault while on and immediately outside a party bus while in the City of Cedar Rapids. Dustin claims Spencer Newman and/or Josh Burns assaulted him, causing him injury. The Defendants have affirmatively asserted self-defense.
02/26/2018	Polk County	Personal Injury	LACL136153	Franjo Breskic v. Tommy Norris and Hy-Vee Inc.	Adnan Mahmutagic	Kenneth Munro				Plaintiff's verdict: Past P/S - $15,000; Future P/S - $50,000; Past medical - $3,444.80; Future medical - $3,000	In this case plaintiff claims Tommy Norris was negligent in the operation of a semitractor trailer causing a rear end collision with semi-tractor trailer in which Plaintiff Franjo Breskic was a passenger at the time. Plaintiff is claiming damages as set forth below. Tommy Norris was employed by Hy-Vee, Inc. at the time of this collision and was driving a semi-tractor trailer owned by Hy-Vee, Inc. in the course of his employment. The defendants, Tommy Norris and Hy-Vee Inc., deny Mr. Norris was negligent and deny Plaintiff is entitled to damages.
06/20/2024	Cass County	Intentional Tort	LACV026102	Theodore R. Wonio et. al v. Mark and Steven Funk	Alexander E. Wonio	David Welch/Bradley Entwistle	Scott Beattie	Plaintiff	3000	For plaintiff - The jury found that Mark Funk intentionally inflicted emotion distress and caused damages to Andrea Wonio. They awarded damages of $3,000 for mental pain and suffering past and $0 for future mental pain and suffering. The jury found that Steven Funk did not commit any of the intentional torts alleged	On March 11, 2020, Plaintiffs were involved in an altercation with the Defendants in Cass County, Iowa. Plaintiffs claim that Steven and Mark Funk committed assault and battery, false imprisonment, intentional infliction of emotional distress. Defendants deny that they committed any of these claimed offenses.
07/31/2017	Page County	Wrongful death in MVA. Fault disputed.	LACV104785	Estate of Payton Casteel v. Patricia Wray	Alfredo G. Parrish	Janice M. Thomas				Defense Verdict
06/11/2018	Dickinson County	Negligence	LACV027760	Ricky Jeppesen, an Adult Ward, through Legal Guardian Kimberly Jeppesen v. Hope Haven, Inc.	Alison Florence Kanne	Douglas Leland Phillips				Plaintiff's verdict: $100,000
01/09/2020	Polk County	PI - MOTOR VEHICLE	LACL141744	CAROL ANN BARTH VS PATRICIA MARGARET HAMAND	ALLISON ROSE ABBOTT	KELLY WAYNE OTTO	WILLIAM PATRICK KELLY			Defense verdict	This case arises from a two vehicle crash which occurred on August 4, 2016, at approximately 7:15 a.m. the intersection of Mulberry and 10th Street in Des Moines, Polk County, Iowa. The Plaintiff was northbound on 10th Street. The Defendant was westbound on Mulberry. Both parties claim the other is at fault for the accident.
02/13/2020	Story County	PI - MOTOR VEHICLE	LACV051012	RICKY LOVE VS LISA FLYGSTAD	AMANDA HASSID	KENT A GUMMERT BENJAMIN MICHAEL WESTON	AMY M. MOORE			Plaintiff's verdict: Past medical - $7,557; Past P/S - $25,000; Past loss M/B - $15,000; Future P/S - $37,500; Future loss M/B - $45,000	In this case, motor vehicles operated by the Plaintiff Ricky Love and the Defendant Lisa Flygstad collided on East Riverside Drive in Ames on November 29, 2016. Plaintiff Ricky Love was operating a street sweeper to clear the road. Just prior to the collision, Defendant Lisa Flygstad was driving in the same direction behind the plaintiff. Plaintiff Rick Love alleges that Defendant Lisa Flygstad negligently operated her vehicle. He further alleges that as a result of her negligence, he was injured. Defendant Lisa Flygstad denies that she is at fault for the collision and denies that the accident was a cause of the injuries claimed. She further alleges that Plaintiff Ricky Love was negligent in his operation of his vehicle.
04/15/2024	Boone County	Failure to Disclose/Breach of Sale Contract/Material Misrepresentation	LACV041812	Michael Morrisey v. All Iowa Homes, Inc. et. al.	Amanda Hassid	Kirke Quinn	James McGlynn	Plaintiff	8500	$8500.00	This is a civil case brought by the Plaintiff Michael Morrisey against the Defendants All Iowa Homes, Inc. Plaintiff claims that Defendant All Iowa Homes, Inc. did not disclose certain defects with regard to a house that he purchased from All Iowa Homes. Plaintiff claims the failure to disclose defects violated the seller’s obligation to disclose the information and constituted a material breach of sale contract. Plaintiff also claims that the Defendant made misrepresentations to him.
02/13/2023	Scott County	Breach of Contract	LACE134898	Eldridge Lumberyard, Inc. v. Difco, Inc.	Amanda M. Richards	Steven Ames	Stuart P. werling	Plaintiff	8023.66	Plaintiff $8,023.66	On or about March 29, 2021, Plaintiff Eldridge Lumberyard, Inc. and DIFCO, Inc. entered into a written contract for the purchase of kitchen cabinets. The parties stipulate that the total cost of the cabinets was $11,917.03. DIFCO, Inc. paid half down at the time the cabinets were ordered with the remainder due at the time of delivery. On May 17, 2021, Eldridge Lumberyard delivered the cabinets to DIFCO Inc. at the requested location. To date DIFCO, Inc. has not paid the balance owed under the contract. Plaintiff Eldridge Lumberyard asserts DIFCO Inc. breached the written contract by failing to pay for the cabinets. Eldridge Lumberyard seeks damages owed under the written contract, plus finance charges and interest. Defendant DIFCO, Inc. denies it breached the contract. DIFCO Inc. has filed a counterclaim in this matter asserting that Eldridge Lumberyard breached its contract by failing to perform as contracted and seeks damages for the same. Eldridge Lumberyard denies it breached the contract and denies DIFCO Inc. was damaged to the extent claimed.
01/11/2016	Muscatine County	Alleged dog attack of goat herd	LACV022556	Baxter v. Schneider	Amber J, Hardin Eric M. Knoernschild	Craig A. Levien				Plaintiff's verdict for $10,674.79.
03/05/2018	Delaware County	Wrongful termination	LACV008271	Deborah Ferguson v. Exide Technologies, Inc et al.	Amy Beck	Thomas Wolle				Plaintiff's verdict: Lost wages-$45,606.40; Past mental P/S - $12,000	This is a civil case brought by Plaintiff Deborah Ferguson against Defendants Fred Gilbert and Exide Technologies, Inc. Ms. Ferguson was employed by Exide Technologies, Inc. from 2012 to 2016. On November 2, Defendants asked Ms. Ferguson to submit to drug and alcohol testing. Believing the tests violated the law, Ms. Ferguson refused to take the tests. Defendants fired her because of her refusal. Ms. Ferguson then brought this lawsuit, making two claims. Ms. Ferguson’s first claim is that Defendants violated Iowa law by demanding she submit to an illegal drug and alcohol test. Iowa Code section 730.5 sets forth requirements for workplace drug testing in the private sector. Section 730.5(8) provides strict guidelines employers must follow when selecting employees for drug or alcohol testing. If an employer fails to meet the requirements set forth in this section, it has violated Iowa’s drug testing law and is subject to civil liability. Ms. Ferguson’s second claim is that Defendants’ decision to fire her for refusing to take an illegal drug test also violated the public policy of the State of Iowa. An employer may not fire an employee for a reason that violates the public policy of our state. A public policy violation is present when an employer terminates an employee in retaliation for performing an important and socially desirable act, such exercising a statutory right or refusing to commit an unlawful act. Refusing to submit to an illegal drug test is the type of protected activity on which a public policy claim may be based. The Court has already found as a matter of law that Defendants violated (1) Iowa Code section 730.5 and (2) the public policy of the State of Iowa when Defendants fired Ms. Ferguson for refusing to submit to an illegal drug test. Because of those findings by the Court, your only task is to decide the monetary value of Plaintiff’s damages. Ms. Ferguson claims damages for lost wages and benefits, as well as compensation for her emotional pain and loss of enjoyment of life. You may also decide if Defendants should be required to pay punitive damages.
08/21/2024	Polk County	Civil rights,employment,discrimination based on disability,failure to accommodate disability,retaliation	LACL152618	Michael McCane vs State of Iowa et al	Amy Beck, David Albrecht.	Chris Deist, Ryan Sheahan	Jeanie Vaudt	Defendant		For the defendant	In this case, Plaintiff Michael McCane (Plaintiff) raises three claims against Defendants, the State of Iowa and the Iowa Department of Corrections (together, Defendants), under the Iowa Civil Rights Act (ICRA). First, Plaintiff alleges Defendants violated the ICRA by discriminating against Plaintiff because of Plaintiff’s disability. Second, Plaintiff alleges Defendants violated the ICRA by failing to provide Plaintiff a reasonable accommodation for Plaintiff’s disability. Third, Plaintiff alleges that Defendants violated the ICRA by terminating Plaintiff's employment as a correctional officer at the Iowa Correctional Institution for Women (ICIW) in retaliation for Plaintiff requesting a reasonable accommodation for his disability. Defendants deny Plaintiff’s claims and deny that any of their actions were unlawful.
01/05/2015	Polk County	Negligence - House Fire	LACL126311	Hopp v. Bermudez	Andrea Flanagan	Jack Leverenz				Result Unknown
12/19/2018	Winneshiek County	BREACH OF CONTRACT	LACV026203	KEVIN & GAYLEEN MOELLERS V JP FITZGERALD, INC	ANDREW FRANK VAN DER MAATEN SCOTT LAWRENCE	DAVID L RILEY	JOHN J. BAUERCAMPER			Defense Verdict: Breach of contract counter-claim - $8,966.84	In this case, Plaintiff, Kevin Moellers and Gayleen Moellers, ("Moellers") claims it entered into a contract with Defendant, J.P. Fitzgerald, Inc. d/b/a Fitzgerald, Inc. ("Fitzgerald”) for the purchase, installation, maintenance and repair of dairy equipment. Moellers claims Fitzgerald breached the contract by failing to install the proper equipment, maintain and repair the equipment it sold to Moellers. Moellers claims it has suffered damages as a result of the breach. Defendant Fitzgerald denies that it breached the contract with Moellers. Fitzgerald further claims Moellers owes money to Fitzgerald for the work performed by Fitzgerald at Moellers’ dairy.
01/30/2023	Fayette County	Nuisance	LACV055970	Mark Vagts, Joan Vagts, Andrew Vagts, and Vagts Dairy, LLC v. Northern Natural Gas	Andrew F. Van Der Maaten and Scott Lawrence	Bret A. Dublinske and Brant M. Leonard	David Nelmark	Plaintiff	4750000	For Plaintiffs - $4,750,000 Loss of Use and Enjoyment of Land $500,000 Economic Damages after March 12, 2016 $3,000,000 Personal Inconvenience $1,250,000 TOTAL $4,750,000	In this case Plaintiffs claim that Defendant created a legal nuisance on Vagts’ farm, and that the nuisance caused them damages. Defendant denies it created a nuisance.
03/21/2019	Linn County	PI - OTHER NEGLIGENCE/INTENT	LACV089439	GUMAA HASSABALLA VS WOODLAND SQUARE INVESTMENTS LL	ANDREW GILLER WILLIAM GORDON NICHOLSON	WILLIAM HENRY ROEMERMAN	SEAN W MCPARTLAND			Plaintiff's verdict: Past medical - $4,607.74; Past loss of earnings - $2,500; Future loss of earning capacity - $70,000; Past loss M/B - $5,000; Future loss M/B - $15,000; Past P/S - $5,000; Future P/S - $35,000	In this case plaintiff Gumaa Hassaballa claims his landlord, the defendant Woodland Square Investments L.L.C., was negligent in certain particulars and its negligence caused him bodily injury. The defendant Woodland Square Investments, L.L.C. denies it was negligent and claims the plaintiff was negligent and his negligence cause his injury.
12/15/2014	Polk County	Negligence - Auto Accident - Red light / Green Light	LACL128714	Drake v. Luncsford	Andrew Heiting-Doane	Andrew Hall				Verdict for Defendant: Plaintiff 100% at fault
09/17/2018	Winneshiek County	CONTRACT/COMMERICAL - OTHER	LACV026156	Debra Flynn; James Flynn v. Dale Donahue	ANDREW JAMES CASPER	Pro Se	DAVID P ODEKIRK			Plaintiff's verdict: James Flynn -- Past P/S - $15,000; Past mind and body - $25,000; Future mind and body - $35,000. Debra Flynn -- Past P/S - $15,000; Past mind and body - $25,000; Future mind and body - $35,000	In this case, the Plaintiffs, James & Debra Flynn, claim that they were injured as a result of a motor vehicle accident that took place north of Decorah, Iowa on August 31, 2014. The driver of the vehicle that struck the Flynn's vehicle was Dale Francis Donahue, the defendant in this case. The defendant admits that he ran a stop-sign, he admits that he was traveling in excess of the speed limit, he admits that he T-Boned Plaintiffs' vehicle, and he admits that he was charged and convicted of Operating While Intoxicated, Third or Subsequent Offense. The defendant denies that he is at fault for the accident and he denies that the accident caused injury.